Phoebe's Cakes and Cupcakes


Menu & Flavors

Phoebe's Cupcakes™
Each Half Dozen Dozen
$2.95 $17.45 $34.80

For orders over a dozen, please call ahead to avoid a wait. Please contact us for prices on wedding cupcakes and other catered event orders.

Phoebe's Cakes™
6" layer cake
(serves 8)
9" layer cake
(serves 12)
Cupcake cake
(serves 8)
$29.95 to 39.95 $39.95 to 59.95 25.00

Pricing depending on number of layers and special customization. Cake orders require 24 hour advance ordering (773-868-4000) for flavors available the week of your order (see available flavors below). All 200 flavors of cakes and cupcakes are available if your order is placed 7 days in advance.

Phoebe's Pies™
Mini Pies Large Pies
$6.95 $23.95

Pies are seasonal check with store for availability on pie flavors. Please place your pie order 24 hours in advance (773-868-4000).  All pies are locally grown organic and can be made vegan with the exception of key lime and lemon meringue.

Pie Flavors: Pink Apple, Apple, Cherry, Plum, Key Lime, Blueberry, Pumpkin, and Sweet Potato.

Bakery Items
Cake Balls
(blended of frosting, cupcakes and chocolate)
Short bread cookies $2.35
Scones $2.35
Cinnamon Rolls $2.95
Phoebe’s Cupcakes Coffee™
Large (20oz) $1.75
Medium (16oz) $1.50
Milk Chug $1.75
Bottle Water $1.00
Harney and Sons
Ice Tea and Juices
Hot Tea $2.00


Flavors of the week

Our menu changes from week to week, so make sure to check back to see all the new flavors each week:

Pumpkin NEW
Pumpkin cake with cream cheese frosting.

Key Lime Pie NEW
Key lime cake filled with fresh lime curd topped with white chocolate butter cream and graham cracker.

Tres Leches NEW
Vanilla cake soaked in three milks topped with caramel butter cream and coconut.

Lemon CranberryNEW
lemon cake dotted with cranberries topped with vanilla sugar cream and white chocolate bark. 

JUMBO Cupcakes $3.95 NEW
Strawberry Stuffed Red Velvet, Stuffed Cookie Dough, Caramel Apple Crunch

Sprinkle cake with sprinkle sugar cream. 

Vanilla cake topped with chocolate sugar cream.

Death By Chocolate
Chocolate cake with a fudgy chocolate frosting. 

Salted Caramel 
Vanilla cake soaked in homemade caramel with caramel buttercream frosting topped with Himalayan rose sea salt. 

Red Velvet 
Classic southern red velvet cake with white chocolate cream cheese frosting topped with red sprinkles.

Peanut Butter Fudgy Brownie
Chocolate cake with a baked in cream cheese top with peanut butter Italian butter cream.

Very Vanilla 
Vanilla cake topped with white chocolate italian buttercream and sprinkles. 

Breakfast Cupcakes (AM)
Maple soaked buttermilk cake with a maple butter frosting topped with crispy bacon.


Catering Flavors

200+ flavors of Phoebe's Cupcakes are available to wholesale and catering accounts in Chicagoland area. Example of some of our flavors: 

these flavors are available for special order in our store front with a weeks notice and a minium of one dozen per flavor. Only flavors or the week are available for wedding and event tastings.

Red Velvet
Chocolate and Yellow
with sugar frosting
Black Velvet
Blue Velvet
Pancakes and Bacon
Green Tea
Mango and Cream
Spiced Mango
Strawberry Mango
Kiwi Mango
Cherry Mango
Orange Mango
Chocolate Mango
Ginger Saffron
Raspberry and Cream
Grape Bubble Gum
Strawberry Pop Rocks
Strawberry and Cream
Chocolate Covered Strawberry
Blueberry Parfait
Chocolate Blueberry Lavender
Chocolate Blueberry
Lemon Raspberry Swirl
Lemon Drop
Lemon Lavender
Lemon Coconut
Cherry Lime Aid
Keylime Pie
Key Lime Macadamia Nut
Margarita Cheese Cake
Tres Leches
White Chocolate Sake
White Peach Bellini
Peach pie
Peaches and cream
Green Apple
Apple Cider
Carmel Apple
Apple Pomegranate
Sparkling Pear
Pomegranate Pear
Merlot Poached Pear
Caramalized Pear
Salted Caramel
Salted Chocolate
Blood Orange
Vanilla Champagne
Chocolate Champagne
Strawberry Champagne
Very Vanilla
Earl Grey Tea Truffle
Chambord Truffle
Frangelico Truffle
Coconut Truffle
Peanut Butter Truffle
Cookie Dough Truffle
Chocolate Merlot
Chocolate Valencia
Triple Chocolate
Rocky Road
Carrot Cake
Brown Sugar and Chocolate
Chocolate Banana
Banana Split
Banana's Foster
Banana Nut Cream
Strawberry Banana
Pumpkin Truffle
Pumpkin Bread Pudding
Pumpkin Black Truffle
Ginger Pumpkin
Candy Corn
Chocolate Grande Marnier
Brandy Alexander Cosmo
Cranberry Orange
Apple Spice Wine
Apple Pinot Grigio
Peach Pinot Grigio
Maple Spice
Chai Tea
Thai Coffee
Cafe' Mocha
Carmel Macchiato
Raspberry Mocha
Raspberry Late
Cafe' au lait
Raspberry Cafe au Lait
Blueberry Almond
Lindzor Cookie
Peanut butter brownie
Chocolate Peanut Butter
Snowball (any color)
Toasted Snowball
Sugar Plum
Hot Chocolate
Peppermint Hot Chocolate
Mexican Hot Chocolate
Raspberry Hot Chocolate
Caramel Hot Chocolate
Dark chocolate Ginger Wasabi
Coconut Cream Pie
Strawberry Coconut
Cherry and Cream
Root Beer Float
Irish Coffee
Mud Slide
German Chocolate
Chocolate Chip Cookie
White Chocolate Rose
White Chocolate Violet
Bumble Bee (marbled chocolate
and yellow cake with honey bc)
Orange Rosemary
Pineapple Right Side Up Cake
Chocolate Carmel
Mint Julep
White Russian
Moon Shine
Pina Colada
Mint Chocolate Chip
Candy Cane Hot Chocolate
Malt Ball
Peppermint Pastel
French Toast
Honey Graham Cracker

Fruit Cake
Rum Raisin
Banana Chocolate Cheesecake

Coconut Chocolate Chip
Boston Cream Pie
Cherry Danish
Blueberry Danish

Strawberry Short Cake
Lemon Curd
Orange Cream Guinness

Keep in touch Facebook Twitter